Jachimowicz, JM; Cunningham, JL; Staats, BR; Gino, F; Menges, JI (2021) 'Between Home And Work: Commuting As An Opportunity For Role Transitions' , Organization Science
This page contains a summary table for data provenance for all studies in this paper.
In addition, authors can share with readers information on why they decided to retract or not retract, plans and/or results
for replication efforts, reflections on the process, or anything at all they feel is relevant. They may revise the information
provided as often as desired, and each author is free to present a message of their own, though authors are encouraged to speak
in one voice.
Aggregate responses
Wording of Question Answered by Co-Authors
Question 1: Data Collection Please indicate whether Francesca Gino was involved in
collecting the data for each study. For example, if the study was run on her
Qualtrics account, or she managed the (non-author) research assistant(s)
who ran the study, or she received the data provided by a third party. Please also provide
additional information for the subset of studies where she was involved.
Wording of Question Answered by Co-Authors
Question 2: Have you ever had access to the raw data?
By raw we mean exactly as it was collected. This can mean having
access to the Qualtrics data on the server, having physical copies
of paper-and-pencil files, having a dataset that was sent by a
third party, etc.
Wording of Question Answered by Co-Authors
Question 3: Do you have the data necessary to reproduce the published results?
Answer yes even if due to an error or some other reason the data you have do not actually
successfully reproduce the published results. It's OK not to post the data, it's OK to
post it only later, it's OK saying 'not sure' today and revising in the future.
Gino involved in data collection?
Co-authors have/had raw data?
Data for reproducing results available?
Study 1
No (3)
N/A (3)
N/A (3)
Study 2
No (3)
N/A (3)
N/A (3)
Study 3
No (3)
N/A (3)
N/A (3)
Individual Responses
Julia Cunningham
Gino involved in data collection?
Co-authors have/had raw data?
Data for reproducing results available?
Study 1
No
--
--
Study 2
No
--
--
Study 3
No
--
--
Jon Jachimowicz
Gino involved in data collection?
Co-authors have/had raw data?
Data for reproducing results available?
Study 1
No
--
--
Study 2
No
--
--
Study 3
No
--
--
Jochen Menges
This author did not provide information about this paper.
Bradley Staats
Gino involved in data collection?
Co-authors have/had raw data?
Data for reproducing results available?
Study 1
No
--
--
Study 2
No
--
--
Study 3
No
--
--
Below is a message written by author(s) of this paper. Keep in mind it may be modified at any time.
Written by: Jon Jachimowicz Last update: 2023-07-18
Please note the following information:
1) The four co-authors (Jon M. Jachimowicz, Julia Lee Cunningham,Bradley R. Staats, & Jochen I. Menges) made the following statement: "Even though Francesca Gino was a co-author on this paper, she was not involved in collecting, analyzing, or reviewing the data. More specifically, at no point did she have access to underlying raw data, and was not involved in data cleaning, or analyzing code and output."
2) An ad hoc committee formed by INFORMS (publisher of Organization Science) reviewed the paper along this statement. In their report, they write, ".... to evaluate the academic integrity of the Organization Science publication Jon M. Jachimowicz, Julia Lee Cunningham, Bradley R. Staats, Francesca Gino, Jochen I. Menges (2020). Between Home and Work: Commuting as an Opportunity for Role Transitions. Organization Science, 32(1):64-85. This issue has emerged as a result of the revelation of concerns regarding possible data manipulation on the part of Francesca Gino in some of her research contributions. In our view, this publication in Organization Science does not pose such concerns. Gino played a minor role as part of this authorship team, as indicated in her being listed as the 4th of 5 authors listed in a non-alphabetic listing but rather listed in a manner reflecting the authors’ roles and contributions. Gino was not responsible for data gathering or analysis in this work. As a result, the issues that have surfaced in the context of other research contributions involving Gino are not present in this case. As a result, we feel that this publication should not be tainted in any regard by the presence of Gino as one of the authors and should continue to be recognized as an interesting and important contribution." INFORMS added to this report, stating, "Upon the advice of the ad hoc committee, I write to let you know that your paper in Org Sci does not have any academic integrity issues. We shall continue to recognize this paper to be a high-quality research paper published in Org Sci."
