| Gino involved in data collection? |
Co-authors have/had raw data? |
Data for reproducing results available? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Study 1 | Yes (2) |
No (2) |
Posted (2) |
| Study 2 | Yes (2) |
No (1) Don't Know (1) |
No (2) |
| Study 3A | Yes (2) |
No (2) |
Posted (2) |
| Study 3B | Yes (2) |
No (2) |
Posted (2) |
| Study 4 | No (2) |
N/A (2) |
N/A (2) |
| Study 5 | Yes (2) |
Don't Know (1) No (1) |
Only authors (1) No (1) |
| Gino involved in data collection? | Co-authors have/had raw data? | Data for reproducing results available? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Study 1 | Yes | Never | Yes, and posted online |
| Study 2 | Yes | Don't know | No |
| Study 3A | Yes | Never | Yes, and posted online |
| Study 3B | Yes | Never | Yes, and posted online |
| Study 4 | No | -- | -- |
| Study 5 | Yes | Never | No |
| Gino involved in data collection? | Co-authors have/had raw data? | Data for reproducing results available? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Study 1 | Yes | Never | Yes, and posted online |
| Study 2 | Yes | Never | No |
| Study 3A | Yes | Never | Yes, and posted online |
| Study 3B | Yes | Never | Yes, and posted online |
| Study 4 | No | -- | -- |
| Study 5 | Yes | Don't know | Yes, but not posted |
The following article is being retracted: Gino, F., Kouchaki, M., & Casciaro, T. (2020). Why connect?
Moral consequences of networking with a promotion or prevention focus. Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology, 119(6), 1221–1238. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspa0000226
This retraction is at the request of the Research Integrity Officer at Harvard Business School after the results
of an investigation into data for Study 3a collected and analyzed by Francesca Gino. The investigation
identified unexplained discrepancies between (a) the data associated with Study 3a in the Open Science
Framework platform and (b) the original, raw data collected by Qualtrics. These discrepancies, which
involved 28% of the total data from Study 3a, biased the published results in the direction of the study
hypothesis. A reanalysis of the original data invalidated the previous conclusion from the study. The
report of the investigation did not concern either Maryam Kouchaki or Tiziana Casciaro, who agree
with the retraction.